I Have Rangefinder
Envy
I'd been toying with the idea of getting a rangefinder for a long time. You
hear the rants on rec.photo.* all the time from Leica owners, "only a rangefinder
can be used for yadda-yadda-yadda" with words like "quiet" and "quick focusing",
"unobtrusive", thrown in there. So, I sort of wanted a rangefinder, but I
didn't want to shell out $1,200 for a Leica to find out how fast focusing
and quiet a rangefinder was. I thrust it into the back of my head, toyed
with the idea of getting a Fed or a Zorki, but was turned off by their ugly
apperance and rediculous knob winding. I figured maybe I'd invest in
one of the new T81's when they came out, but the dates keep getting bumped
back, so I back burnered it again. Then while at a gallery opening, I saw
someone running around with this nifty little Canon QL-III rangefinder --
it was so small! I talked to him for a bit and he let me play with it. Definately
way-cool. I went out looking for one, found a bunch on-line but the going
rate seemed to be about sixty bucks, -- still more than I wanted to spend
to find out if rangefinders were quiet or quick focusing.
Over the years, I've developed the power to control what cameras my local junk shoppe will sell just by wishing hard enough that I'll find one there ... crazy, it worked for a pair of Diana's and a darkroom thermomiter. I've not tried to make any Leica's appear, though I once did make a Nikon N2000 appear for $40. (I've discovered that I can also use these weird psionic powers to make the Discovery Channel show programs about submarines, but that's another story....) About two weeks after I saw the QL17 at the gallery, bang, one appears in Ye Local Junk Shoppe for $20 in pristine condition.
Origionaly sold in 1965 the QL stands for "Quick Loading" -- you don't have to wind the film around the take up spool, it's very similar to today's "drop and load" cameras. You put the film in, close the back and wind away.
My first impression is just how small it is. Much smaller than an SLR, even my Nikkormat. A lot of this compactness is the low profile lens -- which becomes something of a detriment. The rings, focusing, apature and shutter speed are all so close together that moving one sometimes means moving all three. I'd also really like it if the shutter speed dial wasn't on the lens, but rather on the body.
| Pros | Cons |
| Very small (fits in my coat pocket) | No interchangeable lenses |
| Extremely quiet | Rings on lens are too close together |
| Quick loading | Shutter speed dial on lens rather than camera body |
| Shutter priority auto exposure | Probably will not take much of beating |
| 40mm lens very useful focal length | |
| Very light |
The Quick Load really works, it's not a gimmik and I wonder why no one really followed it when it came out ... only recently now do you see mainstream cameras with any type of drop and load, though we know the technology has been available and reliable for over thirty years now.... You just pull the film leader out, streach it across the back and close the rear cover. as you're closing, a foot comes down and holds the film in place while the door closes. Very suave.
Let's do a little comparison between this Canon and today's top of the line
(20 years newer) flagship Leica rangefinder. If you want, you may feel free
to flame me for this. If you
make a good point, I'll be happy to include it.
Feature |
Canon QL 17 |
Leica M6 |
| Film loading | Open back quick loading | Two part, removeable base plate "can you hold this for a second? let me fiddle with the back now," significantly slower loading. |
| Weight/ Dimensions | Height 75 mm, Length 120 mm, Depth 60 mm, Weight 620 Grams (including lens) | Height 79.5 mm , Length 138 mm , Depth 38 mm), Weight 580 g (without lens) |
| Shutter Speed | 1/4 sec - 1/500 + bulb | 1 sec - 1/1000 + bulb |
| Lenses | Reasonably sharp 6 element 4 group 40mm f/1.7 fixed lens. | Legendary optics. Wide range of oustanding quality interchangeable lenses, also inexpensive 3rd party Russian optics some of which are extremely high quality. |
| Self Timer | Yes | No |
| ASA range | 25-800 | 6-6400 |
| Flash Sync | leaf shutter syncs at all speeds to 500 | ~1/45 sec |
| Auto exposure modes | Shutter priority | None |
| Flash | on camera hot-shoe or PC sync, no TTL though does have GN flash metering. | Hot shoe or PC sync. TTL on newer flagship models |
| Durability | Questionable, certianly wouldn't take a serious pounding. If it breaks though, throw it away, get another. | Legendary durability, can't be crushed by a tank. |
| Price | ~$80 used with never-ready case. | ~$1,790, used w/ 35mm f 2.8 lens. |
Back to my Photo
Pages
Back to my homepage